Walmart's AI chat checkout converted 3x worse. Here's what works
When ChatGPT let people buy without leaving the chat, Walmart's in-chat purchases converted at about a third of the rate of shoppers who clicked through to Walmart's own site. That is according to a Walmart executive quoted by AI Business. In March OpenAI scaled the feature back, saying the first version "did not offer the level of flexibility" it wanted, and let merchants use their own checkout.
So is selling through AI a flop? No. It just moved.
I build Shopify stores, and the big change this autumn is that AI has become a shop window, not a till. Look at what is live or rolling out:
- Shopify, Editions Fall '26: connect your store to Grok, Gemini, Meta's Muse and Microsoft Copilot, pin Shopify in the ChatGPT sidebar, and sell in Google Search's AI Mode and the Gemini app with Shopify checkout.
- ChatGPT, since 10 November (beta): claim your business, upload your product feed and, in the US, publish an agent that answers questions and links to your site.
- Square, since July: US food and drink sellers with Square Online Ordering can take orders through ChatGPT and Claude. They were opted in automatically, with no extra commission "for now", per eightx.
The pattern is simple. AI finds the customer. Your own site closes the sale.
What I am doing for clients this month:
- Clean the product feed first. Titles that say what the thing is, real sizes, real materials, stock that is actually in stock.
- Add compare-at prices in Shopify Catalog, so shopping agents can show a genuine saving.
- Write delivery and returns policies as plain answers. That is what agents quote.
- Keep checkout on your own site and make it fast on a phone. That is where the conversion lives.
- Once a month, ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Grok for your product category in your city and see whether you show up.
The AI does not need to sell for you. It needs to send you the people who are ready to buy.